Skip to content
Advertisement
Leadership · Women Leaders

Laura Kavanagh Calls Women in Leadership to Fix Broken Systems

Laura Kavanagh highlights the challenges women in workplaces face at the top and how rewriting outdated systems can unlock leadership potential.

By · 4 min read
Laura Kavanagh Calls Women in Leadership to Fix Broken Systems
Share

After a series of historic firsts for women in the recent elections, Laura Kavanagh came across a headline that revealed a deeply frustrating pattern. The headline in question was a story published by The New York Times that asked, “Did Women Ruin the Workplace?” The headline was later softened to “Did Liberal Feminism Ruin the Workplace?” but the message signaled an old reflex: blame women for systems that continue to resist them.

In her Fortune.com article, Laura Kavanagh talked about this response, citing her own experience when she became the first woman to lead the New York City Fire Department. She was also the youngest person to hold that role for more than a century. She noticed that media coverage zoomed its focus only on her being the “first,” and the things she didn’t share with her male predecessors, but failed to acknowledge the experience she held that many of them lacked.

Laura Kavanagh said, “We still treat women at the helm as exceptions and judge them by a blueprint built for men. The question isn’t whether a ‘perfect’ woman can endure the old rules; it’s whether we’re willing to rewrite them.”

The Reality of FDNY Job Demands

Laura Kavanagh described common assumptions about FDNY work. The image is familiar: a large firefighter charging into flames, hauling someone to safety. But the real image has another side too. She noted that most emergency calls deal with complex medical or emotional crises. Only about 4% of calls nationwide involve actual fires.

On any given day, the crews respond to cardiac arrests, overdoses, and mental-health episodes; they steady panicked families; and they coordinate multi-agency responses. What many label “soft” skills are actually mission-critical hard skills.

Despite that executive nature, Laura Kavanagh said she often faced questions about why she wore a suit instead of a uniform. Many people assumed her to be a spouse rather than the boss. Those reactions reflected a culture shaped by long-standing expectations.

The Challenge of Being the Only

Women make up a unitary 2% of New York City firefighters. Laura Kavanagh stated that even this small share is historically high and is a result of years of intensive recruitment, training, and retention efforts.

She sheds light on the reality of walking into rooms not designed with women in mind. She noted that women who are Black or brown, queer or trans, disabled, or immigrants face even heavier pressure. They can conform and risk criticism for not doing enough, or push for change and risk labels like troublemaker or not a culture fit.

She wrote, “It can be deeply lonely to be ‘the only.’ Not just for lack of peers, but the constant second-guessing of your qualifications and how much of your true self you’re ‘allowed’ to reveal.” Research she cited shows that women seen as competent are often seen as less likable, and women who show care are often seen as less competent.

Taking the Leap Toward Change

Laura Kavanagh provided a way forward. She said leaders must be honest about job requirements. Wider visibility makes more individuals eligible and thus enhances competition.

Kavanagh also implied that women’s lived experiences shouldn’t be treated as baggage. What are perceived as character-building strengths for men are framed as liabilities for women. This scarcity sets impractical expectations for all women who dare to stand up.

The fix, she wrote, isn’t a flawless woman at the top. “It’s more women at every level hired, retained, promoted, so a woman in charge is unremarkable.” She cited decades of studies that show women in leadership increase productivity, enhance collaboration, inspire dedication, and improve outcomes.

Support That Sustains Change

Laura Kavanagh called for scaffolding through mentorship, sponsorship, peer networks, and leadership training. She recalled advice she once received: don’t speak with other women in front of male colleagues because it would trigger suspicion and punishment. Though isolation can’t support recruitment or retention.

Through the Women inPower Fellowship at 92NY, Laura Kavanagh found support that allowed candid conversations and serious engagement with challenges. The fellowship remained a core support system that encouraged her to speak openly and help clear a path for others.

Laura Kavanagh urged women who serve as the only voice in a room to start with small actions. Bring a colleague who has never been present. Pass the mic when someone rarely speaks. Influence, to her, is a practice. When women reach top roles, she said, they should remember one thing: “It isn’t that you don’t belong in that room. It’s that the room has never belonged to someone like you before. Firsts are milestones, not finish lines. What matters is what we change once we get there and how many more can follow.”

Associate Editor

Bettie Buchanan is an associate editor who edits and writes across the magazine’s business and lifestyle coverage. She focuses on women in business, career growth, and the changing world of work. Her stories feature founders and professionals going through major career changes. Bettie also curates the magazine’s lists and annual special features. She lives in Boston.

More from Bettie Buchanan →

More on Leadership

See all Leadership →
Entrepreneurs Edit
Read like a founder. Every story, every morning.

Cover stories, founder interviews and The Daily Edit newsletter — the stories founders talk about.

Subscribe Get the newsletter