‘You Can See Everything’: Amanda Seyfried Gives 1st Interview About The Buzzy Documentary, And Discusses Her ‘Aggressive’ Dinner With Billy Evans
Amanda Seyfried has finally spoken about her surprise role in You Can See Everything. In a joint interview with the film's directors, Nathan Fielder and…
Amanda Seyfried has finally spoken about her surprise role in You Can See Everything. In a joint interview with the film's directors, Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, she gave her first on-the-record account of the documentary. She says she has no regrets. She also explained how she joined the project, why she wanted to meet Billy Evans, and what happened at the tense dinner scene.
How the Project Found Her
You Can See Everything was directed by Fielder and Oppenheim and reached theaters on Oct. 16, 2026. The official description says it begins 34 days before Elizabeth Holmes is sent to prison, when she invites a skeptical film crew to follow her.
Fielder says he got Seyfried's number through Emma Stone. They held a 30-minute video call, and she agreed to let the crew come over with cameras. The plan was to show her what became the first half of the film and talk about it. He noted that she did not go through any talent reps.
Seyfried says she first thought Fielder simply wanted advice about playing Holmes. When he told her he had about 90 minutes of footage, she was open to it. After the call she was ready to do whatever he needed, she says, because of his energy, the time he had put in, and the secrecy around it.
She also says she was already involved before her agent and lawyer knew. She called that far from the normal process. Her lawyer then had to set up her deal after the fact so she would be protected.
OUR VIEW: Joining a project first and calling the lawyers later is not how stars usually work. It shows how much trust the filmmakers earned. It also shows how little protection she had at the start.
No Scripts and No Approval
Fielder says the team did not want to talk through scenes or show Seyfried scripts in advance. They asked her to show up and respond on camera. He stressed that she had no creative control over the project.
Seyfried put it more bluntly. She had no approval over anything. She also admitted that she felt risk the whole time, including a worry that she could hurt her own career.
She says her Holmes voice returned through muscle memory, since about 10 hours of deposition tapes shaped her Dropout role.
Why She Wanted to Meet Billy Evans
Seyfried says the early footage left her with strong negative feelings about Evans, Holmes' partner. She says she turned into a kind of detective about him and felt she needed to meet him. It felt dangerous, she said, but she wanted answers.
She says she tried to give him the benefit of the doubt, and she felt bad about how harshly she had spoken about him before. Yet nothing changed once they met. In her words, it only got worse.
What Happened at the Dinner
Seyfried recalls the moment the talk turned sharp. She said, "There was no reason for him to get that aggressive." She added that she chose that word because it sounded more diplomatic. In her view, Evans disrespected her, and she decided to argue her point.
She says she wanted to defend herself while keeping enough rapport to stay in the house.
Oppenheim says he does not recall her asking for any of it to be cut. Seyfried says she never reached a point where she wanted to walk away, though she came close to saying no to the re-creations.
OUR VIEW: Everything here is Seyfried's account of a tense evening, and Evans is not quoted in this interview. Her choice of the word aggressive, and her note that it is the polite option, suggests she is still weighing how much to say.
The Call From Holmes
During the visit, Holmes phones. Seyfried says nobody knew the call was coming. She recalls sitting with Holmes' children and their dog while Holmes was in prison. Fielder says everything outside the scripted re-creations, including this call, happened in real time. When people ask her if it was really Holmes, Seyfried says it is a documentary and asks who else it would be.
No Regrets Despite the Risk
Asked if she would do something like this again, Seyfried said she does not regret it at all. She is having the time of her life right now, she added, but she does not plan to do it again.
Her link to Holmes goes back to The Dropout, where she played Holmes. That role won her the 2022 Emmy for Outstanding Lead Actress in a Limited or Anthology Series or Movie, according to the Television Academy.
OUR VIEW: Seyfried has now played Holmes twice, once in a scripted series and once on camera in a documentary. Her answers suggest she values that trade.
